Our Cookies

The Basics

Choose your favorite. Then decide on the details.

These naturally Gluten-Free cookies are amazingly delicious! Get them delivered!

Bites of Paradise

1/2 lb starting at $25.00

Naturally gluten-free cookie bites. Get them delivered straight to your door! You'll be glad you did!

Made with pecans and walnuts

A close-up of our chocolate chip cookie.

Choco-Chip Cookies

12 starting at $15

A classic choice--buttery, chocolatey goodness with a slight crunch. Happiness delivered.

Available with or without nuts

Contact Us

We'll Get Your Order Rolling

Name

Email*

Phone

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

A Vacation in Every Bite™ Made for You!

The Florida Keys Cookie Company

Made in a cottage food operation that is not subject to Florida’s food safety regulations. Our cookies are not subject to sales tax.

Privacy Policy
Terms and Conditions

Islamorada, Florida

Yes, cookies!

The web kind as well. Here's our disclaimer. We may use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data might be aggregated with all other user data. We will never sell your data! We just want to know how our site is working for you.

No cookies for me, please.I'll take your cookies!